Services
Independent external review
A non-biased mechanism for providers and payors to resolve payment disputes. Providers and payors contractually agree to use ESMSEF as their independent external review organization.
Performing independent external review since
Medical reviews completed since inception
Days to a determination, generally
From receipt of all materials
Of clients with ESMSEF since 1991

URAC-accredited as an Independent Review Organization: External Review since 2013.
One program, three review types
How the program is organized
The program
Independent External Review
Fair, unbiased written determinations substantiated by the medical documentation submitted and issued in a timely manner.
Medical Necessity Review
Whether the care provided was medically necessary and delivered at the appropriate level of care.
Learn moreReview type 02Coding & DRG Validation
Whether the ICD-10-CM/PCS codes and the DRG assigned are supported by the clinical documentation.
Learn moreReview type 03Cost Outlier / Billing Validation
Whether a high-cost inpatient claim is supported, from admission and length of stay through itemized charges.
Learn moreIssues reviewed
What a dispute can involve
Issues reviewed include, but are not limited to:
Medical necessity
Whether the care provided was medically necessary.
Level of care
Whether care was delivered at the appropriate level.
Readmissions
Whether a readmission is related to the prior stay.
Experimental or investigational services
Whether a service is experimental or investigational.
Coding & DRG assignment
Whether codes and the DRG are supported by the documentation.
High-cost inpatient claims
Whether an outlier claim is supported through itemized charges.
The outcome
What every case receives
Whichever review type applies, and whoever submits the case, the result is the same kind of document: a written determination both parties can rely on.
- Reviewed by a conflict-free reviewer matched to the issue
- Board-certified physician in active practice for clinical decisions
- Certified coders on coding and DRG questions
- Substantiated by the medical documentation submitted
- Shared with both the provider and the payor
Generally rendered in 30–40 days from receipt of all materials
Common questions
About our review services
What is independent external review?
It is a review of a disputed payment decision by an organization that is not affiliated with either the provider or the payor. Providers and payors contractually agree to use ESMSEF as their independent external review organization, and ESMSEF issues a written determination substantiated by the medical documentation submitted.
What issues can ESMSEF review?
Issues reviewed include, but are not limited to, medical necessity, experimental or investigational services, readmissions, level of care, and coding and DRG assignment.
Does ESMSEF perform utilization review?
Yes. ESMSEF has more than 40 years of utilization review experience. Within its independent external review program, this work is performed as medical necessity review.
How long does a determination take?
Decisions are generally rendered in 30–40 days, and under 45 days, from receipt of all requested materials.
