All resources

Resources

How does an independent external appeal work?

When provider–payor disputes go to external review, and what happens next.

Short answer

When a provider and a payor cannot resolve a payment dispute between themselves, the case goes to the independent review organization they have contractually designated. That organization reviews the medical documentation and issues a written determination shared with both parties.

Last reviewed October 2026 · ESMSEF

When an external appeal is used

An external appeal follows a dispute that internal discussion or appeal has not resolved. For example, a payor’s determination that an admission was not medically necessary, or a disagreement over the DRG assigned to a stay.

This guide covers disputes between providers and payors. Patient appeal rights are set by state and federal law and are handled through the patient’s health plan.

The role of the contract

The contract between the provider and the payor is what makes an external appeal possible. Both parties agree in advance to use an independent external review organization. Without that provision, there is no defined path for an independent review.

The steps

  1. Designation: the provider and payor contractually designate the review organization.
  2. Submission: the case and its medical documentation are submitted securely and checked for completeness.
  3. Assignment: the case goes to qualified reviewers with no conflict of interest.
  4. Review: physicians, nurses and coders review the case against nationally recognized criteria, as the issue requires.
  5. Determination: a written determination is issued timely.

How long it takes

At ESMSEF, decisions are generally rendered in 30–40 days, and under 45 days, from receipt of all requested materials.

Common questions

Common questions

Who chooses the independent review organization?

The provider and the payor, in the contract between them.

Do both parties receive the determination?

Yes. The written determination is shared with both the provider and the payor.